A n d re w H
d
a m m o n
Sa la fis m h a s r e s s e d its c a s e in r e c e n t y e a r s a s t h e e x p r e s s io n o
p
ha s m a d
te r m
tiv e S u n n i Is la m in b o t h b e lie f a n d
p r a c t ic e T h e
.
ks w he
p u b lic d is c o u r s e in E n g lis h s in c e t h e 9 / 1 1 a t ta c ,
e lt w a s s u c h th a t t h e r e w a s n o c o n v e n t io n o n h o w t o
\ 11 th
y
bu t in d m e it s u r r e d c o n s id e r a b le s c h o la r l in t e r e s t , a t f
y
p
e x a n d in
t te r ı iııt h e
p
y
g fie ld o f tr a n s n a t io n a l s a la ń m ı b u t la
2
th e d e s i
t
o
m
s
i
c
ı
a
ti
i
t
o
n
it
ı
s
o
e
lf
a
n
d
e
i
d
e
th
o y
reprt
\
g
to r in A r a
b ic d is c o u r s e , w h ile o f lo n g e r d u r a t io n t h a n it s e l
y
in o th e r
岫 \ g e s , r e m a in s r a t h e r v e x e d In t h is c h a p te r ıo
c hr o n
e n ıs h ı
bı
ic a n a l s is t h a t a t t e m
t s t o b r in g o u t s o n ıe p r o
y
p
e
n
e
t b e Is
g a lo gy, its c o n t e s t e d s e t o f m e a n in
a n d its r o le in
g
o f Sa
īn
u d i fo r
ittle s t u d ie d e x a
ei n
l
o lic , lo o lc in
at
g p
y
g
en a
g ge m e n t
T h e Ir a n withkey
ta r
a l ı in ıp °r
d
e
ia n r e v « tt io n
ll
a
n
i
s
19 7 9
g
W s te
e c ti
n
d is c o u r s e o n ıs la m
e o r
t
h
j
y
Modernization
ı
in to
'
'
,
.
.
-
.
"
.
_
'
_
e
s
r e
.
14 7
Scanned by CamScanner
th e
e n tr
a
f Sa ı
o
y
p
l a n d p ° litic a l im
M id d le E a s t h a s fo u n d
s o c ia
jo u r fo r
du
t r a d itio
ith
w
u n
ı
s la m
ic c iv i
b le d iv i n
fo
n ew
l
in
a ir e
c u s
r e a tio n
liz a t i o
n
'
ft e r
a
,
c i b le
du
re
ll
a
v ie s t o
tw e n t
c o
n
c
y ń
-
pt
e
ly (A r a b ) g e n
a u t h e n t ic it
y of
e ar
to
h ic h
w
to
S a la fis m
.
d e r s t a n d in g Is la m in t h e
'
n a l O r i e n t a lis t s c h o la r s
t e x ts
e
g in
a
,
th e
p r o g r e s s iv e ly c o r r u p te ď , a s S h a h a b A h m e d w r it e
c a li h a t e in S
p
} ia a n d Ir a q h a s o n ly a c c e n t u a t e d
'
s e m a n t ic v i c t o r
i
n d e fin i n
th
e W e s t s c o n s t it u
y
g
Jo s e p h
d is p u
u n
M
te s
d e r sto
p °lic y
m
e s s e n t ia
O th
D
e
Th
a
e r
to
in
be tw
o
d
a
ke r s
an
-
te r m
l sa ı
ih
-
ď
p h r a s e is
e e n
d ifte r e n
s
,
d th
an
d
aca
-
5
y e t a s s u r e d Id e
t r e n d s w i t h in
Is la
n o t
t
p lic a t in g
are c o m
lis t Is la m
lin in g
e
a ssa
'
de m
'
e
c o m
lit e
ra
.
th e
m
lis t
pro
c e ss
e n t a r ia t
an
d
'
,
.
B
u t in
le g a lis t ic
p
,
b ly im p a c t e d b
y
ia is in e v i t a
'
S a la fis m
t
S a ld is m
'
s
'
S a la fi
'
a n
d S a la fis m
'
d e r iv e fr o
m
t
he
(th e p io u s p r e d e c e s s o r s )
d ic a t e
phr a se u n de r st
e r a t i o n s o f M u s lim s
, °
t
h e fir s t t h r e
e
ge n
h a v e liv e d in a n e x e m
p la r y m a n n e r s in c e t h e h a d f
y
o f th e P r o
p h e t o r liv e d b y th e s t a n d a r d s o f
th o s e
is o f a d ifte r e n t
g e n u s r a t h e r t h a n d e s c r i b in th e ń
t o b e d e lo e
g
p y d a s a r e fe r e n t fo r t h o
s e c la i m in
a dh
o f u r is r
g
u
d
j
e
n
t
i
a
l a n d th e o lo i
p
g c a l p o s it i o n s , u s in g
14 8
Scanned by CamScanner
7
r e v iv a lis t m o d c r n is m
o f i
h o o i t r a d itio n ; a n d th c
'
d
M
u
h
m
m
a
n
a
a
d
A bd
9
7
3
8
18
)
i a l A fg h . . (
r o u h w T itin g s in a l M a n a r , R a s h id R id a (1
g
190 5 ) M a in ly th
'
ıth r e e
f A b d u h , a t t e m p t e d a s y n t h e s is o f a ı
a dis c ip le o
t h a t w o u ld e n a b le I s la m ic c u lt u r e t o m c
v a lis m
o r ie n t e d r e v i
'
b n T a y m iyy a c o n fig u r e d
A bdu h an d ı
w
i
th
e
r
o
u
E
,
le n ge o f
p
e d t o t h e S a la f in t h e ir d is c o u
lig u r e s a Y e t w h ile a ll a p p e a ı
m s e lv e s S a la fis o r d e s c
th e th r e e g r o u p s o r ig in a lly c a lle d th e
9
a
fi
a
l
a
d
S
ll
e
c
a
l
o
i
d
e
o
n
f
a
s
n
o
r
e
t
s e lv e s a s a d h e
yy
gy
'
d e r w e n t c o n s id
m s v e r b r o a d n o t io n o f S a la fis m
i
-
-
-
.
.
,
'
lo gic a l a n
M
us
b le
to
su fi tr u t h
d e fin
'
1o
,
f
tr a n s o r m
a n t ic
lim B r o t h e r h o o ď
w as a
a
u
y
d se m
e t
bu
t
ĥ fth g e n
s
a t io n
e ra
in
ıc o
n
'
he
o
by
th e 1 9 8 o s t h e t e
rg
a n iz a t io n
as
a
fe
n
su
bse qu
rm
19 3 8 H
r e n c e in
S a la fiy y a
de ca
en t
m
ha d b e c o
e ssa
m
e
as
ge ,
th e
n d to
° litic a l s c ie n t is t s t e
d
a
y p
yy ,
'
th e S
m
B r o th e r h o o d a n d its e e r s a s ' ı
sı
a m is t , d is t in c t fr o
p
th e m e a n t im e a n d in lin e w it h th e Is la m ic p ° lic y o f F a y
,
cro w n
t h e 19 6 0 s h a d
m
p r in c e a n d k in g , S a u d i A r a b ia fr o
d e r n is t
s ite fo r
s h o r n o f th e m o
e la b o r a t io n s o f s a la ĥ s m
to h d f
c e n tr e d o
a a n d th e a n t i
q
n a n a li n m e n t o fw a h h a b i
yy
g
to e t h e r
e n d in g w
u
sha re d
g
e r h a s m o r e c o m m it m e n t t o
p
p
p
'
'
B ro w n c a ı
m o dh h a
o f th e
ls t h e la t e s u n n i t r a d itio n a lis m
'
o rde r i
'2 s a la fis m
th ir d s ta g
s
n
g o f s o c ia l a n d r e lig io u s life
m u n ic
19 9 0 s in t h e
iz a t io n a n d th e c o m
c o n t e x t o f lo b a ı
g
ı
u tio n
w h a t o liv i
, th r o u
h
w h ic h th e s e t r e n d s m e r e in t o
g
g
a de t
a n is l
e r r it o r
n in
m a
i
i
a
i
i
ı
o
o
g
z
d
e
e
d
l
i
t
r
a
a
n
s
n
a
t
io
n
'
gy ' g
T ıT h is id e o l
o n d
e t h n ic it
r
e
t
u
i
u
c
d
n
y , r a c e , la n g u a g e a
W ah h a b i
a
s u
c
h
th a t t o
-
.
,
.
Scanned by CamScanner
d b y M u s lim B r o t h e r h o o d th in k e r S a y
th e a p o s t a s y o f p ° s t c o lo n i a l M tıs lim r u le r s T h e
t e r m e d a ıs d ı
a l ta n z i m \ (o rg a n i z e d / a c t
is
flu
in
e n ce
-
.
-
p o r ts
in K
so m
ı jım
p a t io
n
to
le r s
o
B a h r a in
ru
in
f
th
e in
Sety
M
th
e m
at
flu
en ce o n
S t u d ie
j
e i er
'
s
h e r th a n
w
r it o
v o
lu
c o n s id e r s
gg le
r e n t c an
n a t io n a
'
.
It
can
fin d
l s tr u
v a r io u s
.
h is t o
an
d
f sha r i
in ile u s e
a t io n a
a
'
a
fu
sa
lly s h iftin s e
g
d is c ip lin e s ( lu s m e d ia
p
as a
18
s
r ic a
.
m
e o
it s
b e d d e d in lo
s tr u
te s ta tio n
'
u
rat
l p o litic
.
p r o c e s s e s o f p o litic a l c o n
a s lo n
g a s th e y e n su r e th e
y p r a c t ic e
g
n a t io n a
17
f it s \ a r d ia n s , th e
ı
a m a
W
a m o d e l fo r u n d e r s t a n d i
n
g tr a n s n
fıe r s
in
in
d E 田中t ) T h e t h ir d , o ft e n
'
'
S a la fis m ), is q u i e d s t 1 6 in t h
en t o
rar
e n t
a n
,
(s c h o la s t ic
\
-
m
le v e l o f in v o lv e m
e
u w a it ,
'
a
-
a
-
c a
o n
a n ic
g g le
c
fte r s
han
a m
c e s
d e l fo
o
w
e a
k
w
l p r a c t ic e s a n d
ly s u c c e e d in
he
o r
t
m
he
p r e d ic t in g th
h e r e th e
p °p
r
e n
.
n a t io n a
lis t
m
b e lin k e d
c an
X
o v e m
e n
w i t h a la r
g e r g lo b a
h e p o litic s o f id e n
t it
y in W e s t e r n E u r o e h
s t a n d a r d it h a s
p ,
n o t be en
su c c e ss
M a m o n p a le s t
in ia
o f w a h h a b i in fl
g
u e n c e th r o
u
g h p a le s t in i a n s t u d e n t s
in
to
t
'
w
he
re
is
re
g rd e d
th
a
t
he re
e x is t s s o m
as m
o re o
e r e is a c o n n e c
t io n
e t
h in
g
o
f a h is t o
f a Sa u d i i
m
o
fso
m
po
r ic a
r t 22
an
e n at
u re
to
t
he
lba se
2 1
,
d Fran
po
st
-
Scanned by CamScanner
c
19
o
f b o th m o d e
al Q
a l a l D in
an ı
-
g
d s r c g a r c lc «lW
a n ta
g
ovef a c e n tu r
叩p
p
e a te
n o t re
p
.
ity t o
d ly
(
an a tte m
t to
y do n
a tta c
a b s tr a c t n o lın
o
e
,
a hha
o u
lin
f
n
hW
ha t he
t
N a b il M
d e liv e r e
t
avo
'
s
e n o te s
he r
in
n o v a to r
b iy y a
id e d
'
-
-
h r o u gh e m
th c S a u d i s c
t
'
its e
Ye t
th e
to
re
lf Ib n A b d a l w
-
h ile t h is d o
w
ań
Sa ı
w
av e
,
es a
it is
p
o n
an
a la fi
yy a a s
g S a la ĥ / S
e fo r e
n w h ile a s s e r t in g b
r le a
t h e im a m s o f a ll fo u
g
u s in
a t io
p e c t fo r
th a t th e t e r m
r e s
.
hh
ha d b
'
d in
p p e lla t io n
ih
a l s d lo f a l s o ı
an
ahh a
o t
ahh abi a
lF d e s ig n
se
b iy y a
o
a
g io n a l
1 929 A bd al A zi
Is t a n b u l a n d
-
m u a
in
H a n a ñs W
it h
e n t th a t
o v e m
u s m
fo llo w in g th e
s c h o o l (m a d h h o b ) in
ew
i ddid),
a ren e w e r
tia ll
w
th a t in
re se n t a n
p
re
s
a
i io
ı
g
a
pe e c h
r e e c t th e W
j
y In
a
-
a
n o r m
°n is d c
°r t u n
fa r , 2 6
o
A lth o u g h b o t h tr e n
'
R id a s w o r k o Hė r e d th e S a u «li W
25
.
liz in g
r e la t io n s M p
fo r
av e n u e
to
y
it
m
an e x tr e
i
a s im
-
J
re
q
rn i
a
l
-
ta r i \
a
ıs a lq fw
(th e
f W ah h a
-
'
d b y A b d A lla h Ib n Q a s im in M s a n t h o lo g y o
w o r d is p °s it
a l D u ra r o l S a n i
b
u t h e r e a g a in t h e
4
3
a
19
,
)
yy
(
is
u se
-
-
co n
h e S a la f th e m s e lv e s , n o t
T 8 A t th e
r se
u
o
s
c
d
i
r
i
e
m o v e m e n t s w h o d e lo
t
h
f in
p y th e S a la
bu ke , W a hh a b
R e dis s i n o t e s t h a t d e s ite A b d a l A z iz
,
p
fa c t e m b r a c e d d u r in th is e r io d b m a n y W a h h a b i s c h o la r s
y
p
g
29
a ra e
i
s
d
o fh o n o u r
t
o
s
a
n
e
m
g
a
p
a ft e r it s lo n
g M sto r y a s
S a la fis m a s a n id e o lo c a l tr a d e m a r k o n ly r e a lly ta k e s o f
g
d is c o u r s e in 1 9
t o f th e g °
6 o s s a u d i A r a b ia , in t h e c o n t e x
n asc e n
ic a n d th e
t
r o e c t io n o f a n Is la m ic fo r e ig n p ° l y
p j
1
Sy r ia n a
D in a i A lb a n i (
n t i ta ı
id
h
a d ith s c h o la r N a s ir a l
q
196
N A lb a n i i
s h e r e in
n t r o d u c e d th e t e r m
t o th e S a u d i p
a d e c t iv e
j
ho
w
se
re
fe r e n
t is t
.
'
'
-
'
s
r e
.
-
-
-
-
Scanned by CamScanner
th
e
Is la m
in
ce
p tio n in
H is b a G
U
ic
n iv e r s it
19 6 2
an
y
d
o
a
fM
d in
e
l Ja m
-
a
h e r e h e ta u
l S a la ĥ yy a a l M
a
w
'
a
-
a
-
p , o r S a la fi G r o u p fo r P r o m o t in g V ir
V ic e ) e s t a b lis h e d b d is c i le s o f a l A lb a n i in 19
6
y
p
m e m be r shi
p in t h e S a la fi H is b a G r o u p , a fa c t i
Ju h a y m a n a l U ta yb i in 19 7 9 le d a fa ile d in s m r e c t
al H u
i r e c o u n t s h o w S a la fis m w a s t h
\
e to u c h
m e n t : he w a s m a de f
a m i lia r w i t h th e w o r k o
fal
S a la fi c o m m u n it in K u w a it
y
, a n d le a r n e d tł
ı
a t b e in
g
in g th e in t e lle c t u a ıtr a d itio
n o f th e s c h o o ls
in c lu
(
32
A sh
i th e o lo
g y ) A l A lb a n i p o s it io n in s ir e d
p
p a s s e d th r o u g h S a u d i A r a b ia , 3 1 h e l e d b
p
y h is c lo s e
A b d a l A z iz B in B a z
(1 9 10 9 9 ) a n d h is o p o s it
p
a c t iv is m
o f th e M u s li
m
B r o th e r h o o d d e s i
,
p te t h
fo r c e d o u t o f th e c o u n
tr
y in 1 9 6 3 a n d o n l a b le t o
y
o v e r t h e fo ll
o w in
t
w o de cad
3
◆
g
e s
S im ila r t o t h e
w h
ro u
-
'
.
-
'
'
a r
-
.
'
s
'
.
-
o
'
u
b je c t e d to
o
la m
'
a
.
a
i q a s im
-
in S a u d i A
r a b ia
i
sc
-
.
S a la fi
yy a
th
e ir
a n t i ta
-
t5 2
u se
as an
is t o
q lid g r o
u
i
d e o lo
day O
.
p
as a
o
dvo
gr o u p
lde c a de s
se v e ra
m
f 19 6 0 s
to m
u ta te
s ta x o n
o m
g ic a l
t to
8
fe lt th r e a t e n
e d b
y th e
h o o lß h 3 s
q
It w a s fr o m t h e
m i lie u
d is c o u r s e o f S a la fis
m
be an
g
o u s fa c ti o n s c r
o s s in
g v a r io u
pre
'
n o t
d 19 7 0 s S a u
, e x
p a n d in g to
ic a l a n
d e o ra
g g
a n
in
m
an
e a t in
a r ke r i
s s t]
-
g , g iv e
T u r k is h h a d
it h s c h o
la
g la
-
ï na
dhh a bj
yy a
'
(
n
o
Scanned by CamScanner
-
s
ro u
g
ho
w
p
so u
gh t
in io
叩
fr o
n s
al
m
A ı
ban
-
Jo r d a n
i in
38
,
f S a la fiyy a in a m o r e s y s t e m a t ic m a n n e r in M i
im m a t
H e d e s c r ib e s le a d in g W a h h a b i s c h o la r s a s
8
3
9
1
)
(
9
a l
y an d w a
(im a m s o f th e S a la fi N a jd i c a lı
o
n o t io n
'
'
,
.
idinu
en t c
er n m
-
Sa
s a J
le r ic s
ho
w
a
f r e s p e c ta b ilit y,
au r a o
aJ
-
(19 8 9 ) h e
d iT o
'
u
4 o
d叩
la b e l S a la fiyy a
t th e
h ile in
w
c o n
de m
lKaw
a
-
as
t
he
ßKu
-
'
lls g °v e r n m e
S a id R a m a d a n a l B
'
(a l s a 14 i)? 1a
h ií a l Ja ti)w
ha t he
n s w
g ve
to
c a
4
lim
l h u k u m i H 1a ) 1 S }T ia n
20 13 ) p u b lis h e d t w o r e fu t a t io n s o f th e a l A lb a n i p °s it io n ,
ıIs la m iyya 1\9 6 9 1 a n
bo b i a A kh t a r B id Tu h a d d id a l S h a r i
-
a
-
-
a
.
-
'
'
n
Ta
-
in
M
a r
ha ł
o Z a m
壁山a b ĐT
m ał
19
th o s e
a
b a r a ka L a M
a
o
n
a
o
-
89
'
a
a
a n i
u
yy
in t h e fir s t b e c o
'
E g y p tia n
th e
M
a
lim M
Uharibun
a
ı
ßq h
a
l
-
m a
ham
m
a
fo
tr a d id o n
'
h o ń g rt t h e ßq h
w
u
d h h a b Is la
S a la fiyy a
e s
m
-
d
r
d h h a b i ıi h js d b
t
in
m
i 119 8 8 1 ,
he
se c o n
d
4
.
l G h a z iJ i (19 7 1 9 6
t h e s a k e o f a n a lle g e
a
-
-
salaN
'
m a z
u m
a
)a s
e
44
h e p r o v o ke d
h ild is h \ h a ď (a ıjjtih a d a l s u b a n i) ,
e n e b e °n d
re s o n s e fr o m
y
e S a la fi W a h h a b i s c
i
n
t
h
n
ı
a
n
p
y
c a u se he w a s
w ith s o m e s u
S
a u d i r in t m e d ia , b e
° r t fr o m
p
pp
+s
h a d a c q u ir e
in th e lite r a lis m o f th e ir t h e o lo
S
a la fis m
g
gy
a ı
°n d th e a n t i t q
o f id e n t it a r ia n v a ı
u e in W a h h a b i c ir c le s b e y
Sa l
O n t h e w h o le in t h e e r i o d u p to t h e 19 9 0 s w h e n
p
te x
th ir d s t a
e r in t h e c o n
c
t
a
r
a
h
c
a
l
n
io
t
g e t a k e s o n it s tr a n s n a
n , w
iz a tio n
o u s p °s it io
u
i
b
a
m
a
n
e d
a
, W ahha bi
g
y y a m a in t in
i on s in
he 叩
am a '
n
t
e
e
w
t
t
e
b
e
s
re e d o m to ch o o
dvting
f
a lle i
th e e x t r e m
n
c
ti
e
e
a n «Je t o o n e
r
t
u
b
g
sc ho o l
j
g
partiar
so i
ofun
o u lin e a l
M
il
b
a
n ıe d ia t e d a
N
t
s
c c e s s t o d iv in e t e x
as h
d e lir e a n ı
e m s e lv e s
th
s
h
i
l
b
t
a
s
o n
e
g th e s a u d i la m a t o
'
c
-
_
-
'
'
.
-
,
ı
łl
a
,
.
'
'
u
Scanned by CamScanner
l p r o p e r ly
u sc «
h ile
w
,
d
a r e n o t c o n s ld c r c
W o rı
d Le \
in 19 8 7 th a t
o
'
fa M
l Ju n
a
by
fa n
fa m
n o w
a t ic is m
a
-
al
in
A lb a n
-
i
m
is le a d s a n
n a
l in 2 0 0 5
Is la
m
19 6 0 s
th
)
ro
e c ti o n
' "
J r
fr o
19 6 4 ,
si
in
le
°
'
so
.
d
a
)
in
w
as
f Is la m
ı r ıa
Bu
ķ
t as
w it h
in
T h is d e c is io
S a u d i r e im
g
co n
den
pd n g d
ic a l r e u
q
acce
can o n
h o o ls p
'
h a t e ń ıl m e t h o ď
e a n t
n
N
lim
ic
s ta t u
e lt '
fa
y
b e g in
fm
e o
po w
s , ho
w
i
-
sc
as re
er as m
gyp
d d e lo m
p y
e r e
w ev e r se
s a l a s s e r te
E
p la y w
in
g fu l in
to
ean
tha t
"
a s s e r is t
it e
o t
t w
h is
is s u e d in
in
ea
e n t o
Is la m
e t
h Is la m
te
\
tio
a m
flu
e
d
en c e rea c
h
lf, fo
ll
se
k e n e d , th e
f Is la m
R a b a t , th e O
qg a n
e s t a b lis h e d i
'
n
19 7 2 a
m
ly
it
n p r o c la im
d hh n
n ııa
g im
o lo
re
a s a to
it in
s
th e
fu r t h e f
t
f»reign p o h q
g h is
L u
a 1 9 6 9 su m
(O IC
ro
a n
b ilit ie s
g
i
,
n t ie r s
o
v o c in
-
as a
\
d
an
T he M
.
w m
ta
u
,
'
"
49
,
g p o h c y d id n
W o fa n y sc he m
p j
ers, b
y in
e
d d iv id e s
re i n
W
.
dh h a b
m a
-
d Sa u di
a n
S a u d i fo
ı
a
s
48
n a
i lia r v ie w
a fi W a h h a b i
p p o s e d to t h e S a ı
l id a ), b u t c o n d e m n e d th e e x t r e m
'
ly M
n o t o n
F iq h C o u n c i l
ic
th e
ls
o
pa r t
-
'
"
k
to o
d n g th a t
as
Is la m
dh h a b ı (s c h o
m o
o
'
I
e
a sse r
ic
w o r
h r o u gh
ı
ď
th
e
sı
.
la r
S in
ce o n
g e sse
a
iz a t io n
pe n
o
ııa n e n t
ly in d ir e
c
b e s to
w e
f th e I
d
u
t
po
ir
be n
n
t
ıs 4
Scanned by CamScanner
h
r n a t io n a lis t a im
w ith in te
a ro u n
n iz a t io n s
m o s qu e s a n
b
dis
i u d n
M
re v o lt in
d m i) w
js ı
d
sc
re
g
th a t
Is la m
,
a
m
ic
im
m
d in g p r e a c h e r s t o M u s lim c o m m
1 9 7 9 , s h o r t l b e fo r e
a t e r ia l In
y
.
d r iv
e w
n
o
s e n
u s
n a t io n
p ls e
to
e s t ic
an
u
w
f s u p p °r t in g M u s lim y °u t h a n d s t
'
r ld ,
s
p r e a d in g ta w h jď (u n ic it y
'
to w
e
ar
d s Is la m
h e o c c a s io n
a t e r ia l la i d o u t p la n
d iv i d e t h
n o w
T h is
h o o ls ,
la tın c h e d
m
d in is tr a t iv e
ho le
th e
lig io
ecca
a m
w
d
s o
o n
t
a c r o s s
,
Is la m ic
e
v
ie w
t
n a
tio
c o m
he M
m
n a
u s lim
o
f th e fo
s
fo
l,
u n
ic c o
r a c
ity
r n ew
u r te e n t
n
J
(o ı
h Is la m
in s t it u t io n s s
ia l, lin g u
'
h e s io
'
u
d
is t ic a n
o t
54
.
e x t e r io r a s a n
are n a
fo
w a s r e n e w e d in l
g °n is t s
le ftis
th e S o v i e t b o ls t e r in g o f its
M e c c a in s u r r e c t io n
id e o
A lg h a n is t a n a n d e ls e w h e r e , a n d Ir a n ia n r e v o lu t io n a r y
d L
fir s t r e s °n s e t h e °v e r n m e n t u s e d th e M u s lim W o r l
p
g
d A
M u s lim B r o t h e r h o o d , a n d p a k is t a n i Ja m a a t i Is la m i a n
s la m ic U n
n e tw o r ks
l
e d th r o u g h th e I
w h ic h h a d in t e r m in
(
g
a M d in ń g h tin g
M e din a ) t o fu n n e l e o ı
e a n d c a s h to t h e M u j
p p
ba c k e d A f h a n r e im e s s O liv i e r R o m a k e s t h e p °in t t h a t
y
g
g
n m
u lf c r i s is , w h e
r a t e a llia n c
G
1
0
9
19
e
th
w
b
e
a s b r o ke n
y
d i A r a b ia
r o u s c o n d e m n e d th e U S t r o o
s e n c e in S a u
e
r
g p
p p
e Sa
im e r ia l a
e s °n s e t h
56
r
r
o
a
m
d
n
o
c
p
T h e se
j
p
\ e s s io n
o n e
a d o te d
r o s e ly tiz a t i
a
l
b
o
l
s
t
w
i
a s th e e x
p
p
g
p a n s io n o f
o n o f
ta lcin
n e w e d it i
a
d
e
r
o
s
n
°
o w e r in 19 8 2 K in
gp
g Fa h d sp
o r P
b r M a s s d is tr
o m p le x f
c
d
h
F
a
n
i
K
ib u d o n t h r o u
h th e
g
g
a r pu
'
ĺı
ol
c e a iA zh
in
s
n
i
k
t
a
y Q u r a n , th e fir s t s u c h ıın d e r
g
an
vers
e o tt o m
th
io n in 19 2 6 fo ll
f
o
n
io
t
u
l
th e d is s o
o w in
g
P o tm e r
e a r n in
s la m ic l
I
f
o
s
w a s s h iftin
e
r
n
t
fr o m t h e o ld c e
g
ah
Ąr ab ia
a la fi W
s
o
t
in
s
i
a
s
n
t e r r e t a d o n o f th e t e x t w a s
;
g
p
p
bo th d o
m
d fo
re i
gn
a n ta
,
-
.
-
.
-
'
'
Scanned by CamScanner
g
19 9 2
s o le
ı
n
s tu
in in
he
av o
he
in t e n
w
h ic h
Is la m
em
d y T h e Ib ilu r e
ly in th e
ex am
u
c o n te x t o
g
id s t h c
fo
ly
O llv le r
tw e n t lc t h c e n tu
-
ı
r e
ı
s la m
-
lm
ste r e
d by
Th e Se a r c h
ß,
b r a c e s Sa ı
a fi a
yy
tio n
'
S a la ti , p r e fe r r in ' n e
g
t r a «ı
itio n o f d is e n a e m
·
h ift
ear
lls t h c
ca
'
t e 】m
d s th e
w as
f th e
ha t h e
w
f Po lıtlc a ııs la m
o
'
la m
u
'
a
In
N e iv U
a
th e
m m a
d e s c r ib e
to
ha s
g g
o
-
'
o
fu n «l
en t
fr o
S a u d i o r b it
.
h , p u b lis h e d
t h is
m
o v e m
e n
k e n p la c e S im ila r l , th e
y
'
o f R a m o n d H in n e b
u s c h s s tu d
y
y t he in te r n a t io n
E a st
t a n d a r d w o r k in t h e fi
e k l, c o n ta in s a ı
m o st
d e p lo m e n t o f ı
s la m
in t e r n a t io n a ll 6 o
y
h w h ile t h e 2
Is la m ia a t io n o f fo r e i n o l
g p ic y itin g s u p p o r t fo r S
a n d S T ia in t h e c
o n te x t o f c o
j
itic a l c o n flic t w
g po ı
F r o m a t h e o r e t ic a ı e
p r s p e c t iv e S a u d i A r a b ia e
its r e io n a l c o n n ic t s
w it h ı
g
ra n a n d Su
n n i
itic a
po ı
tiv is t m o d e l in in t e r
n a t io n a l r
e la t i o n s t h
eo r
y a rg
c u ltu r e a n d id
e n t it
y c a n d e lin e a t e , d ir e c t a n d
,
c h o ic e s o f r e im
e
s
T
h
i
s he l e d
g
p
p r o d u c e th e n o t
s h e r e t h a t is c r
e a t e d th r
p
o u h sa t
e llit e t e le
g
v is io
la t t e r ı
s o c ia l m e d i 6 2
a
h
ı
t c o u id b e
a
rg u e d th a t d e
u s e o f Sa ı
a fi n o m e n c
la t u r e in t h
e do m e s
t ic s h
m e a n s t o b a la n c
e a a in s t s
p
o m e o f
g
th e c h a lle
n es t
g
se m
a n t ic s
, a
th a t
ta
.
s
, c
,
.
.
a t io n a
l se c u
r it
y d ile m
l
m
'
a
p re se n
te
d b Ir a n
y
s in c
Scanned by CamScanner
f
p u b lic a n s e c u la r is m
fr o m p u b lic d is c o u r s e Y e t s in c e t h e 19 8 0 s S a la fi p
Sa u d i A r a b ia h a v e b e e n a b le t o fin d a n ic h e t h r o u g
th a t h a v e e n d e a v o u r e d t o t r a n s la t e A r a b ic t e x t s fr
Tu r ke y
d
an
th
su c c e ss o
e
re
.
W ith
th e
e v e lo
D
im
e n t
m
p
c u s s io n b e a n
g
a
lie n
T u r k e y in
n am
an
he
o v e m
ly
e
e s a n
Jm
e
m
r
as m
n a tio n a
r v a
le m
e
i lita
c
f S a la fis m
f re l
e n t o
'
g im
tte m
rr
a c h a lle n
ge t o th e K e m
ls la m i s m , K
E r ba ka n
e m
as
b le
re
o
t
e t tin
e
s
a
s
T u r k is h Is la m
th e
p °s it iv is m
k is h
s
'
le ft , N
w
rg in g
e c m
.
19 2 3
bse
o
f th
c o n te x t o
d Ir a n T h r o u g h
s in c e
o
'
67
e n ts e m
th e
s c ie n t ific
o
t
S y r ia
in
.
be c o
S a la fis m
vre m
p lic a t io
P a r t y (A K P ) g ° v e r n m e n t
to
q u e s t io n t h e n a r r a t iv e
T u r ke y
to
h a n g e t h e d is c u r s iv e la n d s c a
n
o f m
k is h c i t iz e n s a n d
to c
pt
a tte m
an
s c e n e in
ic
-
ha t ha d be e n
d ifie d
l c u ltu
to
re
.
m
Th
a
ke
(TŁir
h e g u id in g p r in c
fo r Is la m a
ro o m
t
ilita r
e m
S y n th e s is
y
au t
h o r itie s
o
ig i
5 0 p e r c e n t in t h e b u d g e t o f th e r e ı
50
o m
tr a t io n
(k n o w n a s D iy a n e t ), e x p a n d in g it fr
se r d e s w
19 7 9 t o 8 5 0 0 0 in 1 9 8 9 6 8 p u r s u in
,
g c lo
o f m o r e th a n
.
T u r k e y in
itrs t itu
v o
lv e d it s e lf in
t io n s u n
o re m
a m
d e r s a u d i tu
te
la g e
,
e a n in
a n
m
g fu l
d D iy a n
an n e r
e t re c e
de v e l
o E u r o p e to
t
s
a
l
i
ffi
c
d
i
n
d
o
t
o
s
e
n
\
g
69
rk
tie s in T u r
k is h im m ig r a n t c o m m u n i t ie s A n e t w o
cu ı
tu r a l lin k s w a s
d i b u s in e s s e s
e s t a b lis h e d w ith S a u
b a n k in a n
ho u se s , n
s h in
i
l
b
u
d
s
c
e
ĥ
r
v
i
n
a
n
e
c
ia
l
s
g
, p
g
Lea
e
fu
n
.
Z in e s
,
an
d
r
h ilr l,
h
,
Ļ
7o
Scanned by CamScanner
(
\
r e fe r e n c e s
)
h ile t h e y a v o id c o n t e m o r a r
p
y Ta m a
M u s lim B r o t h e r h o o d s u c h a s Y u s u f a l a r a d a w i b
Q
(
s c h o la r b a s e d in
Q a ta r T u r k is h is t h e ir p r im e la n \
tio n b u t A r a b ic i s r o m in e n t in s e c ia l s e
c tio n s
p
p
la n \ 뼝e S a la fi t e x t s in t h e ir b o o k s h s a n d h e v
a
叩 ,
y
n o lo
i
n t h e ir T u r lđs h te ×t s
gy
'
w
,
u
-
.
,
.
The
w
ho
m
se w
o st w
o r
k
e
w i
in 】
r a , Y o lc u
q
ll e s t a b lis h e d
am
-
ll b e d is c u
sse
o n
g
th
e m
is
d in d e t a i l h e r e
A bdu
73
.
A Tu
p e a k s flu e n t A r a b ic a n d p u b lis h e s in
B e fo r e is s u in h is b o o k s in
T u r k is h h e u b lis h e d
g
p
A r a b ia u s in
'
h
i
g s fu ll A r a b ic n a m e A b d A lla h ib
A
th a r i,
w
o r
s o
ks
m
are
A b d u ]h a m
h she d
th
e x tr e m
e
e
s
tim
e s a
d d in
p u bh sh e d
id e l E s e r i
u n
74
-
G
.
g a l Ir a q i o
d e r th e n a m
-
A fte r
se tt
7
P r a c t ic e s 5
.
an
d fr o
Pr e se n
m
u ra
S u fis m
A
n
(ąş
ø
ır ı t a s a
m
arm
o
f Iz m
, a n
ir
g in T u r k e y in
s e in
Is t a n b u l
t e r in
g
a c e n tu r
d th e r e v a le n
p
base d
-
e
d ic a t e Ir a
q
A b d u lla h Y
lin
b a p u b h s h in h o
u
g
G u r a b a d e s c r ib e s a s
t h e a im
o fc o u n
e
in
c
ce o
h a r it y İ h m
D
20 0 5 b e
t a tio n
to
a
ga n to d r a \ o n a o o l
'
o f Y o lc u
p
T u r k is h a u d ie
n c e in
T u r k is h 7 6 W
.
O t to
o
fte n
Sa u
m
an
p e r io d
an
d th e lo
c a t io n
o
f
m
an
y
o
f
a
P p e a r in g in t h e o l
g d r im
di ı
77
a m a
H is b o o k s
av
-
'
'
u
.
o
d b la c k c lo
ak
id
p o litic a l is s
m
e
an
d
u e s su c
Scanned by CamScanner
co n
d itio
fm
n o
th a t th e s h a
in s is tin
or
w o rs
79
y
fi\
h ip
o
.
0
y
th e
o t
o
o t m
fa\
her
o
in
f G o d a lo
te r m
n e
)
,
e n t a t io n
f th e
e
m
a in
hat pu
p °s t s h a r i
o f fa it h , is
s in
p r o fe s s io
m
s t
u s lim
M
o st
u s lim
M
th e r a c t io n
re s a s
d a bb lin g in
an
,
h e fa c e
o r an
°s ta s
f s a in t
ha da
t
praye
is a p
o
g In
y if n
an
n
o n
fo
rsa
k in g
m
an
ds
o
c o m
'
t o n e
Is la m
s
d ia r ie s (a p °ly th
c o m
pr o
m
is in
g
th
e i s t ic
e a
a
ta t e s
s
.
n o t e n o
th
R
e
am
f th e s h a r i
'
a
je o p a r d y in
in
d ilu
b s o lu t e
t io n
au t
f th
o
h o r it y
o t h e r t h a n G o d ), d e
y (a d d r e s s in g e n tit ie s
f Is la m , o r s u gg e s t in g th a t it is a n in c o m p le t e
w o r ks t o
a d e c h o ic e s r e a r d in g w h ic h o f h is
g
so r c e r
y e le m e n t s o
Y o lc u h a s m
ic fr o m S a u d i
p u b lis h in A r a b
c e to w a r
w h a t a d d itio n s t o m a k e a n d w h a t t o o m it N o n c h a la n
th e o n e h a n d , a n d
a n d d is r e a r d fo r d o c tr in a l q u e s t io n s
g
ke
tu r a łh is t o r ic a l r e a c h o f S u fi p r a c t ic e s , o n th e o t h e r
e
H is k e y n o t e w o r k s S e ı
r im e ta
e t fo r S a la fi r o s e l tiz a t io n
p
y
p
rg
e t v e ıC e m
Àłi i (B e ı
ie f o f th e p io u s a n c e s t o r s ) a n d E h ıj S iin n
im a n (F a ith a c c o r d in g t o t h e S u n n i tr a d id o n ) b o t h p r e v io u s ly
in A r a b ic in S a u d i A r a b ia
k t o d e fm e S u n n i s m in S a la fi
j S a lih
e
Se ı
ce
p
te r ıııs , a n d
t o a T u r k is h a u d ie n
u t t h a t c la i m
p
i io u s A fta ir s in 2
w as
u b lis h e d b
a u d i M in is t r y o f R e l g
S
th
e
p
y
B l It w a s is s u e d
a n e n d o r s e m e n t fr o m t h e m in is t e r a t t h e t im e
en t
y
in 2 0 1 3 , w ith th e a d d itio n o f a s e r ie s o f fo r e w o r d s b y t w
fr o m a n tım b e r o f c o u n t r ie s e le v e n o f th e m a r e b a s e d in S a u
;
re sse
e s a y s it e x p
a n d o n e is
"
h
ik
ı
l
l
e
s
i
n
,
fr o m T u r k e y D e ń n g
d
th a t M u s lim s w
th e p r o p h e t
h o fo llo w t h e Q 1ır
in
to
T u r k is h
an
d
w
h ic h
to
re
.
o
,
n
,
-
a
m
.
'
-
-
,
,
s e
e
.
.
.
'
'
s
a n
ex u n
th e
\
p le
o
f th e
a r d ia n s o
im
ly M u s ı
fr o m
fı
s la m
ear
s are t
u n
h
,
e m
b e lie f
an
o st c o r r e c t
d in
.
s u
n
n
Su c h M
t
n o v a t io n ;
a
u
h e Sa l
Scanned by CamScanner
p r a c t ic e s t h a t p u t t h e ir fa it h a t r is k , s u c h a s v is it in
in
g m u s ic a n d s in g in g M u s ic is p r o d u c t iv e o f
p r a c t ic e s s u c h a s m i x in g o f th e s e x e s a n d b o d il
y
d e s tr u c t iv e fo r t h e m o r a l fa b r i
c o f th e M u s lim
c
fa t w a s o n t h e t o ic fr o m S a u d
i s c h o la r s , in c lu d in
p
'
tio n o f a l
Q a r a d a w i s a \ m e n t t h a t m u s ic w a s f
c o n t e x t o f a lc o h
o l a n d o t h e r s in s 8 8
h e a ls o r e r
;
p
2 0 0 0 is s u e d b th e
y
p e r m a n e n t fa t w a c o m m i t t e
S e n io r U la m a in S a u d i
A r a b ia d e c la r i n
m u s ic a n
-
'
'
is s ib le
m
r o se
P
le g itim
,
89
d
m
d a d u lt
o n
H
.
o v e m
g
e
e n ts
th a t
'
th
h a v e in
at
a
lig h t s
'
in Y o lc
P
a r t ic u
o
fA
ra
it s e lf m
a
n
am
S u fis m
'
g h jn
c e
ly th e v o ic e
a t e , w h ile t h
e
o
u n r e la t e
u se
S in
.
.
R e
o m
v e n te
a
d in
e n
u t in s t r u m
lm
e n ta
o n e c o n c e s
s io n
d d in
e
as
u s ic
h e b e lie v e r h e a r s s h
o
t
(h is
at w
d b y S a la fis
o
9o
gs)
M
.
is t
u s ic
te s t
d
g
fo
n e w
re
t e x t s in t o
o s t c le a r
p r a c t ic e s
ho
v o ic e
an
j
a
i
r m
yy a
f in
th
fo
e
u
ha t
is
in
s
]d
n
g G
su
u r
se n se s
n n
iti
qu
c r
d [z i
i le a
g
r
T u r k is h
ly u n d e r s t
o
in T u r k is
h w
e is e a s i
S u fi s e z n a
to
fo
u r se
'
o
.
T u r k is h d is c o
ly Y o lc u
in h is r e fe r e n c e
v o
he
91
'
.
s o
d by
e c te
la r b Ib n T a m
y
y
b ic
it
de r sto
u n
fa u lts d h ik , r it u a
ls fo r c la
p p in g , s h o u
lik e e o le w h o
d r i n k a lc o h o l'
p p
ix in
, m
lo v e a n d d e s ir e a
g
n d e x ci
'
u
w
w o m
w
is
g
,
in
to
g s h r in
g
e s
he
rave s o r m
w
r it e s t
o s
q
u e s
hat
'
th
b u ilt
e
u
ĥ
s i
po
n
'
a
t
a n
he m
s o
,
】
cn
o w
ł
n
a s
Scanned by CamScanner
t
lo s o p
g
,
s u fte r t h e s a m e fa t e
w ho m a
r
)
e
y
i
l
z
ń
(
R
94
T h e t e r m B a t m ile
a e in
e n
e
n
s
t
h
io
t
v
a
o
n
in
c
i
f
g g
y
th e s p e c i
'
'
I
m a ili S h i a a n d o t h e r s w h o
s
o
t
i
n
n
d
e
a
i
t
in
g
A r a b ic B a
yy ,
ic h in t in T u r k is h o f
w le d e , c a r r ie s t h e s e m a n t
e s o t e r ic k n o
g
r n u a n c e d , is t h a t T
e o v e r a ll m e s s a g e , h o w e v e
r a c t ic e M
p
i s o c ie t y o n t h e e d g e o f k w b e c a u s e M u s l
n o m in a lly M u s l m
r d s o f th e P r o p h e t
i n o r a n c e fa il t o liv e b y th e s t a n d a
g
d is c u s s io n o n t r
S o w h ile T u r k e y h a s b e e n o u t s id e t h e
b s e r v a t io n t h a t S a la fis m m a y s u c c e e d
Sa la fis m M e i e r
'
a
Sh i
e
e x tr e m
a
a c
,
.
.
'
s
s u
n
n
'
,
j
e t is t c u r r e n t c a n
'
w
s
o
ńn d
a n ic
he
o r t
he
n a t io n a
lis t
e n t
o v e m
m
96
In ń g u
e
s
h
c
a
s
r
k
i
T
u
e
h
s e e m s t o s e a k s u r p r is in g ly w
p
to a t t e m p t t
Y o lc u s u c h a c u r r e n t fo u n d a p la c e fr o m w h ic h
n
fr o m A r a b ic t e x t s T r a n s la t io
tio n o f a T u r k is h S a la fis m
a ti o n
n sı
Su s a n B a s s n e t t a n d A n d ré L e fe v e r e a r\ e in Tr a
'
o n te
e r e is a lw a y s a c
T
h
t
n
c
e
n
o
i
n
Cu ı
v
e
r
tu r e
n
e
i
s
19
9
0
(
),
w h ic h a t e
m
w a s a h is t o r y fr o
th e tr a n s la t io n t a k e s la c e , a ı
y
p
97
it is a fo r m o f w
a n d in t o w h ic h a t e x t is t r a n s ° s e ď ,
p
°n a n o t h e r in
e u
in v o lv e s ' th e s h a in
°w e r o f o n e c u lt u r
p
p gp
f a u t h o r it y in t h e t r a n
s o u r c e la n
a e c a n w ie ld a fo r c e o
\ g
u a e te x ts
9
8
te x ť
Y o lc u d o e s t h is in t a ld n g A r a b ic la n g g
h ecu m en e w he r e
A r a b ia a n d fe e d in
in t o t h e T u r k is
th e m
g
ie n c
th r o u h a r t ic u la t io n in T u r ld s h t o t h e h is t o r ic a l e x p e r
g
ie t y H i
ar i
h
m a t e r ia lis
s
t
°s
a
f
o
n
m
a n d its
p
p r o d u c t io
ic e in T u r k e y
in t r o d u c e a s h a '
t o I s la m ic p r a c t
r i a s e n s itiv it
y
o m
o n o f O tt
th a t it im
ti
i
d
a
t
r
e
ir
t
ie s a r e je c t io n o f th e e n
pı
o
ı
a l th e o ı
s la m
g
w it h its e x t e n s i v e s u ń n e t w o r k s a n d le g
a m ic s c h
in d e e d
h e d is m is s e s t h e m a jo r ity o f r e p u b lic a n Is l
e
ll t o
t
.
,
.
,
-
.
'
-
a
c
s o
.
-
,
Scanned by CamScanner
p u b lic d is c o u r s e t o d a y ) in t h e ir s h a r e d in t e r e
lm o w le d e fr o m d iv in e t e x t s 1o o S c r i tm
g
a lis m
p
r a t io n a h s t im
p e r a t iv e o f th e M g h im p e r ia l
H in d u is m 'o l w e r e n a r r a t e d a n d e
x
p lic a t e d b y E u
n o n E u r
叩 e a n a s c o m p a r a b le a n d c o m p r e h e n s ib
S a la fiz a t io n o f Is la m i c h ls t o r i
o
g r a p h y to o k h
n o t io n s o f d e c lin
e (th e fa ll o f B a h d
g a d , th e r is e
p r e v a le n c e o f S u fis m , th e in t e lle c t u a l c u lt u r e o f th
a n d , a s K h a le d E ı
R o u a h e b h a s a r u e d id
e a liz e
y
,
g
le a d e r o f a c o u n t e r c
u it u r a l r e v o lt
th a t e v e n t u
th e o lo ic a l o r d e r
t o t h e Is la m i c
g
w h o le 10 2 E v e n
t
R a s h id R id a
S a la fis ' s h a r e d th e
b r o a d o u t li
a lth o u
g h A b 山山 d id n o t s e e Ib n
W
yy a a s th
w i s h e d 10 3 A
d e fa u lt o s i t io n
e s t a b lis h e
p
d its e lf
W e s t e r n s c h o la r s h i
p th a t p la c e s la w r a t h e r
th a n
lo g ic a l r e a s o n in
k
a
ı
g ( a m ), o r p lıilo s
叩 诊 o r lo g i
d is c i p lin e s t th e
he ar t o f w hat i
￠
s d e s c r ib
e d a s Is
R e c e n t t h in ]cin h
g a s m o v e d to r e e c t t h is
j
n o t io n
c a lls tim e le s s
S a la fis m
d sh o w n th
a t s a la fis
in v e n t e d tr a d iti
o n o f th
e e arl
y t w e n t ie t h c e n t u r
h
m a rke r o f se U
id e n t it I
y w o u ld a r
in c o n t e m
p o r a r y u n d e r s t a n d in
g is p e r h a p s o f e v e
e n a n c e th a n th
o u
g h t In t h is r e s e a r
ch o n
a tte m
th e t o
p te d t o r e s c u e t h e t e r m
p ic
fo r t h e
a n t i ta
.
-
-
-
.
'
'
s
'
.
,
a
'
'
10 5
a n
-
.
.
-
to th e t e r m
16 2
t
ha n
th e m
o
dern
is t s a
n
d
th
e
q Tid g
ro
w a h h a b is
Scanned by CamScanner
.
Sa la ń s
n e fic ia r ie s o f S a u d i s t a t e fu n d in
g u la r b e
gor
t h a t t h e y s h o u ld b e in t e r p r e t e d a s a n e m a n a t io
are r e
t bu t
p °in ,
Is la m ic im a g in
ar
y is
c
le a r
.
Scanned by CamScanner
94
6
H
.
a sso
Co n su m
,
g D
in
e s ir e s
P R O D U C IN G S A L A F IS M
.
p 14
.
,
:
.
FR O M
IN V E N T E D
S 丁八T E A G IT P R O P
1
.
Fo
r
p le ,
ex am
H
J
.
o
叩
er
an
S u s p e c ts T h e B in d in
2
.
Tw
o
t itle s
j
m
a o r
R eı
i jo u s M
ý
g T ie
are R o
o v em en t
,
N
'
,
e
d B
T he G
l M
Yo rk
ew
'
W h ita k e Ą
.
u a r
d ia n
26 0
,
ije
r
(e d )
C
lu
m
e
o
.
Sa l
,
G To b
b ia U
n
iv
O liv ie r R o , G lo b a liz e d Is la m T h
e Se a rc h o , a
y
N
J
C o lu m b ia U n iv e r s it P r e s s 2
004
,
y
A t ic a l e s s e n t ia lis t
t e x t , fr o m
yp
t h e t h in k t a n
H a m iď s fs ı
a m jc E x c e tjo n a ı
js m
H o w t h e S tr u
p
ıe o
ı
w
g
g
W
b ıld
'
ıl
d , N e w Y o r k St M
a r t in S P r e s s
2 0 16
,
Sh a h a b A h m e d
W h a t ıs ı
,
sı
a m ? t he ı
m
p °r t a n c e o f
P r in c e t o n U n i
v e r si
P r e s s , 2 0 16
v
2 19
, p
o
s
e
J p h M a s s a d , ıs la m i n L ib e r
a ı
is m , c h ic a ° : u n iv
2 0 15 E d w a r
g
d S a iď s n o t io n
o f m u c h w e ste r n w
'
'
o f th e
'
A rabs an d I
'
s la m
c r e a tin
o w e r i
g a n o n g °in g
P
n a b s tr a
ct an d
.
.
3
.
-
.
4
.
5
.
.
.
.
re m
"
"
a in s
'
EI R
"
w
o u a
,
in
c o n c r e te
m
o r
y
ks
v ie w
o n
yh e b , F r o
'
m
l
re e v an t
w
a
ys
o v e r
t
h
.
S a la fis m / s a l
a fi
yya a s a n e o
Ib n H a a r
j a l H a y Fa m i (d 15
-
.
su
29 8
n n i
s c h o la r s
'
,
in Y o
s se
f R a o o
p p
r t
an
d sh a
Scanned by CamScanner
R e t h in k g
q
m
fc kr y ib r a h i ,
'
a c h , Jo u r n a l ď
r ic a l A p p r o
o
t
s
i
H
l
tu a
hm e d
ie e A
e
A con c p
j
O
th e A m e r i c a n
ri
-
io u s r e v i v a
lis m
an
d A
ra
b is m
D
se e
av i
d C
o m
m
in s
,
ı
sl
li
ıO n re g
Sy r i a , N e w Y
L a te O tto m a n
h
a n g e in
C
l
ia
o
c
S
d
n
a
p o litics
otm
I￠l
1 9 9 0 a n d Itz c h a k W e i s m a n n , Ta s t
re ss ,
P
r s it
v
e
i
n
U
d
y
O x fo r
d À ra b js m in L a t e O tt o m a n D a m a s c u s , L e i
r
j
ajya
Jladm y Sı
lsm 5aı
Brill, 20 0 1
v
lo p e
m a r k e r in th e m a k in g is d e e
id e n t it
n
a
s
a
t
c
e
o
n
c
c
y
9 Th
p
u d S h u k r i a l A lu s i a n d
190 8 1 3 c o r r e s p °n d e n c e b e t w e e n M a h m
đ
a r e n t a lt e r n a t iv e t o s a ı
an a
=
u s E sa ]
f 2
1 T he
.
,
a n
.
-
-
-
-
,
-
-
pp
￠
y
w e rs
3 So ı
n ftr ı to Ib n T a m i
￠ is u s e d a s a d j
y yya a n d h is fo llo
m a d b in N
ra ll to de s c r ib e lite r a lis t A t h a r i t h e o lo
y
gy S e e M ' u h a m
d A jm i, o ıR o sa il a l M u t a ba d iıa , B e i r u t : a l B a s h a ir , 2 0 0 1 , p p 4 7
Q afim
i:
.
,
.
.
'
'
.
-
-
-
.
Ų
Scanned by CamScanner
0s; bu
\
習
B r o th e r h o
an
o
ビ
지
ー
A n
ち
A b in g d o
19
M
.
S a la fl s m
2l
Lau
.
日
月
刊
j
In
du
tr o
23
N
.
Bo
re n t
.
M
o v e m
M
o
C
24
e n t
e
25
H am
'
a sa n
,
A
D
am
in
su
'
n s
'
m
in
,
a n
a sc u s
gro u
r in
g a
u
M
a
u s a n
19 0 8
D
a she e
e
d ia
e n t
w
am
a sc u s
ce :
f
S a ıa ls
fW
a
d (e d
,
.
hha
)
p ic i o
id a w
v i s it
u s
a s
Se e C
.
K
Lon d
su s
; R
,
o
.
s i s a id
u n
Ta
i,
'
th e
ri
im
S u fis m
P r in
te
d in
M
lin
o u
bo
y
kh N
'
D ie
,
e
r n e
a
ld C
,
a ir o :
M
-
in
a
d
an
.
e x c e s s iv e
ıa ıK
o
v o
u sE
dbo
u
'
a m iı
a ,
l 1, p 8
o f
tair
ly ,
.
n
.
.
-
-
d
.
!
an
p
d
.
U m m
'
s
w e re
m
y , Ja m a l a ıD in a l Q a s i m i
H ıt d e s fs ıa m s S ı 1 2 0 1 1
,
(
)
s ir r
'
n o t
a s
p
-
A lm
.
o
F r o n t ie r s
h h a b iy y a
-
M
Gı
o bo l
l R
d M
a
Fra n
t a ti o n
-
d
,
in
,
an
Saı
afsm
fu
R e
.
27
.
i A
g °v e r n m
p an d W
Gı
o bo l
,
'
A lu
S a u d is
o c t r in e s
(e d )
j
e i e r
daw
D
t
p p 1 17 , 1 3 0 1
Se e M u h a m m a d A b d u h a l À
,
'
A r a b i a , 19 8 0 , v o l 3
5 32
yy
, p
.
°
A
e n
S a la fis m
d i R e d is s i , T h e
O tt o
lt d
'
u i,
in M
,
.
'
a
Ye m
in
(e d )
j
e i e r
d A ı
i A drao
.
26
da r
B o u n
.
b iv a le n
m
-
19 3 2
-
T he
T he
.
Sa u di P o ı
itic a l R e ı
i lo
g
.
.
'
,
、
d ia
.
p 29
,
o
e
2 0 16
,
'
c t io n
in M
,
d ic tio
o n tr a
17 4 5
N
in
,
to
d in g J ih a d i T e x t
h a M e llo r a n d
e rea
f h S a la fis m
'
ham
Se e
.
r se
dge
n n e o
h a id i H
o u r
'
c e
.
G lo b a l S a lo ł
j sm
22
d, R
o n
pp °
o
,
.
'
d G lo b a l M
a n
R o u t le
n
'
e i e r,
i
-
P o lit ic a l ł
sł
a m
医
a
a n
dre w H a m m
d P o lic y D is c o u
Se c
.
p °litic is m
o f o b e d ie n
it s
d d o c t r in e
h is t e a c h e r a l A lb a n
in c lu d e s
18
d,
in
t,
c
la im
o u t
a
t
by
l
-
ųy ra
h a t t h is
th e s
,
16
am
pe e ch
o u n
as
y 1 9 2 9 , fr
t e d to r e
p la c i
M
a
p u b lis h e d
.
Scanned by CamScanner
31
p
m an : n
Am
,
'
髯tte s
]2 N
.
'
asir a
-
M u htd sjba
dı
-
Jp
ı,
] H u z a ym
,
/
b\
m
B e ir u t
J. h q
m d
rab
A
N
m a n
e tw o rk
K
'
m o
u n tu
fo
r
R
,
e se arc
l jQ m
-
h
an
ł
'
Q
o
-
Q
d P u bı
'
i t o o k th e S a la ĥ b a n n e r w i t
d
i
W
ä
a
l
il
b
u
M
t
e
n
d
s tu
q
]] A lA b a n i
t h e r o f th e m o v e m e n t
e is c o n s id e r e d th e fa
h
w he r e
e
n
n
a
ı
o Y
,
'
'
Be
ix
c
r
o
a
e
L
s
e
i
a
b
A
r
a
i
,
Sa u d
in
a n i s in flu e n c e
-
.
.
al A
34 0 n
-
.
lb
d A p °litic is m
c r iti u e o f a l A lb a n
q
R e v o lu tio n
15 Fo r
.
'
a
an
-
Se e
.
'
i
in
s
m a
d N
a s ir a
l
.
Ę h
i
Ļ
1c c
on
d e d itio
n
in
,
1
Q a dh i O
,
an
97o
a
in
'
S a la ń Is la m
.
se e
sı
a m
g ı
i B u ti
-
n
C h r is t o p h e r M e l
d T r a d itio n a l H a d ith C r it i
n o v a t io n s
-
-
'
a so
l D in a l A lb a n i
K e n da ll a n d K h a n (e d s ) R e c la i m
M u ha m
in
'
ic
Tıa d itio n
re c o u n
ts a
m
.
e e t in
g
w
Scanned by CamScanner
it
a l M a d h a h ib
a l F iq h i b a y n
l
a
f
i
h
K
l
B i Sh a
F iq h ł o l Is la m i , Y e a
l
m a
o
M
l
a
t
a
ı
l
j
h a b i M o ja
w a s t a k e n in it s
n (
\ rar)
3 8 3 6 T h e d e c is io
pp
-
'
49
-
'
-
a
n
'
.
'
-
-
a
-
,
-
.
.
17
5o
21 0
-
Ja m
p o ic
)
、
：
、
52
'
Ħs c a t o
e s
9 87
1
r i,
.
is la m
V a lu
ic
an
e s
d N
l
a t io n a
b ia , in A d e e d D a w i s h a (e d )
l y
P r e s s , 19 8 3
C a m b r i d g e : C a m b r i d g e U n iv e r s it y
'
t
r
e
s
I
n
t
e
n
a
l
t
io
N
a
n
d
p is c a t o r i , Is la m ic V a lu e s a
G r a n t s a n d lo a n s t o O IC m e m b e r s t a t e s t o t a lle d
im W o r l
1 9 7 6 , a n d M u sı
in
a n d $ 1 9 9 b iM o n
.
51
ber
c to
'
f sa u d i A
o
.
ra
'
.
.
.
b u i ld in g m o s q u e s , p
e tc
In t h e p e r io d ı9 7 5 8 1 w a s $ 2 6 m i liio n ; S
th e M e c c a b a s e d S u r e m e W o r ld C o u n c i l fo r M
p
Is la m ic V a lu e s a n d N a t i o n a l In t e r e s t
p 47
A fr ic a
o n
g im
tr a in in
am
s
,
-
.
.
-
'
'
53
.
P is c a t o
54
.
M
em
G
e n e ra
sin i ,
a
Is la m
du
o ran
、
。
ri,
fr o
m
l D in
w a
-
-
lD
a
-
S a q i, 19 9 0 ,
p 82
Fo r e x a m
p le , th
.
B r o th e r h o
R o y, T h e
n
1
.
56
叢
匦
57
H
.
.
o
d fi\
ı
F Jj u re
e s
an
th e
m
l S e c r e t a r ia t
.
55
V a lu
ic
o
a w
a tio n a
l
ic
Is a m
rg a n
la
d N
iz i n
th
g
ß a ıM
-
A
e
'
l In
te r e st
d e m y in
c e le b r a t io n s ;
c a
ı
a ka
a m
.
.
,
'
ı A r a b\
'
a
-
.
e
re
bu
p L o
as
a
re a u
r e c r u it m
R iy a d h
in
e n t
ofpoljtjcaııs ıa m
,
Lo
fo
c e n tr e
n
do
w
I B
n
.
.
am
En
n a
W
a
as
G
,
hda
u
lf
sto o
d
c
h a p te r s
o
f th
B r o th e r h o
e
h s a u d i A r a b ia
;
e p o litic
s o f
u
w it
lid S a le h '
Th
,
Q
R o
o
d
.
M
o u
lin
e
,
T h e C le r i
cs
o
r ıĮ ıa m
,
r a n ic
p 2 13
.
,
o bo ı
iz
y, G ı
H
e r m
걔
58
r
.
Scanned by CamScanner
u
20 14 , p 6 6 2 B a r d a k o g ļ
6S H \
A ym
e
.
d d in K
l】k
cı
,
20 0 2
/ /w w
(a c c e s s e d
p r e si
.
a r s fo r
ho ı
sc
L a j k D ü z e n d e D in
,
i
Yo ş a
m a
de n c y
h a yr
.
k,
o
o lo
as t
67 In 20 14
Tu rke y Se e
u
p
f th e
N
õ k te m
s e èsı v e D in i R
iR ı
j
d
s t a t e b o d y d e fin e
Te m
in
e
.
.
.
s
o
'
,
S e le fiı
o
c o \ jc t
a n
d c h a n ae
T
th e
in
w e n t ja
S
ss
11 M
,
'
a
th
in
lk
e r s a
,
'
E n g a ge m
s
.
,
Pa t o n
,
f B e in g S e c u la r Is la m
in C e lia K
a l S ta t e
h e r , T h e Im p
N a tio n
a t io n a l a n d p r e
T u r kq
s
p h ilip R o b in s (e d ),
a n d
-
'
k le r k e n
e ri B e
o r ta n c e
Z ū rc
.
/ l/0
z e n
20 15 , p 8 T h e
d
dzm
S e l e , s e Je Pıjı, a n Seı
u
r s b e a n t o d is c
g
r in t m e d ia w r it e
'
68 E r ic
'
a jş
,
fp
ç a lc ır
be r
R ū şe n
.
Mūslūm
'
.
y
hr e e g r o
.
.
i an e t
D
g S
l 1 , Is
a n
b e r 20 16 )
f R e lig io m A « a ir s , D
a n u m
.
e t t in
o r in
v o
'
1 , s e le fiyy e d e n K u r
k a r a m a n n e t / y a z i / la i k d u
o v em
A n kara
,
gy
w
\
s e c t io n
se e
13 N
R a po r u
o
ds
an
'
h ttp
66
an
aram
p r im
re
.
.
h C e n tu r y
,
Lo
do
n
w it h
en t
l dg
R o u t e
n
o r ld q u
T u r k e y , T h ir d W
r i m e n t in
T h e T u r kis h E x p e
'
69
K
.
'
A hm
ro z
ad
2 (1 9 8 8 ) , p
70
.
71
.
72
r
Fo
T \ır k is h
r
Se e
.
p e
/ n e w
co m
73
.
0 th
M
k öz
er s
'
R a blta
lig io
u s
s e ie ń 1e
F e ro z A
r
A
,
g
o
B a lc ı
th
?id
,
H
-
T e
e n ts
d,
k in
u
Y a
f
o
U
ym
th e
'
a n
6 0 0 9 7 (a c
c ıd e
u
in
ğlu )
kara
a
la
A K p k lk o
-
e m
hm
o
.
_
n
o v e m
m
d e t a il p h p
a n ıo n
e h Ŋn e t
B ir
re
,
s
,
n
e a s s e r t io
R
ic
.
c u
u m
M
Is la m
7 6 2 A ls o
.
U gu
,
in
e v i,
d Is m
c e s se d
E n w e
,
M
a il Y a # a
3
P 19
.
,
R u #e n
se e
19 8 0 s
b e y d u lla h A
u
s e y in A b
19 8 7
'
,
T ū r k iy e
c to b e r
2 0
Ebu
dY
3 0
0
r s an
l
,
u rat
Gezmle M
S ai
ı# lk
Scanned by CamScanner
s in c e
81
l o f sha r i
o v a
A b d u lh a m
i
e
Z e de ı
q
en
ve
Bo z a
2 0 14
p 7 35
G
80
rem
u ra
'
.
.
,
l E se r i, E hl j
-
it in
şe y
n
. e r
S iin
tr
,
fo
a
'
n et w
a n s
1 Ce m
e
f apo
o
'
a a t
-
A hm
.
rm
sta s
G öie
e
d İ y ib ild ir e n
.
IşJ
ğJn d a jį la m
'
in
-
.
,
'
K
u r
a
n
,
'
S iin
v e
A b d A lla h b in
S a lih
-
is
b a , 2 0 10 , P P 2 9 3 0 , 6 2
Y o \c u
.
d
la w
a
'
n et
al
A bd
a
d a is la m
ă
H
-
R iy a d h W iz a r a t
in I§ı
.
am
i
ın
d
lA
a
-
m
,
l Is la m
a
-
yy a , 2 0 0 2
i
-
a
şo r t la r ı
ıĺ va ljz ß
.
th a r i ,
-
'
l Sh u
'
b u l in A r a b ic in 19 9 7
M u h a m m e d R a id b H a lid K a r a k ö
ş
y lū , fo r m e r im a m
m o s u e in e a s t e r n T u r
ke y
q
A b d u lla h Y o lc u , S e ı
e
f j S a ljh jn A kjd e s j E M j S iin n e t v e
G u r a b a , 2 0 14 ,
pp 59 , 6 6 , 6 9
A b d A lla h b in ' A b d a l
H a m id a l A t h a r i
a l
,
K h a w a r im u h u N a w a id u h
u
in d A h l a ıS u n n a w a l
q
a m a
J
a l W a ta n
200 3
Is t a n
.
82
.
.
·
83
.
-
-
.
84
.
'
.
-
-
-
'
,
-
-
-
-
,
8S
.
E 1 E s e r i , E ĥ 1 j S iin n e t v
g 1 Ce m a a t
G ö r e im a n ,
p 44
A b d u 1ı
a h b A b d u lh a m
id e l E s e r i
ve G
, M eş r u
q yn m
A hm e t i ß
b
ild
i
r
e
n
an d
y
M u s t a fa ö z t iir k Is
ta n bu
,
P P 1 5 3 7 3 , e s p p p I S S 6 H e iv
g es n o co m m en
r a c t ic e o f t a
p
yiq , a p p lie d b y M u h a m m a d ' A b 山山 T
lis h e d in A r a b ic a s '
A b d A lla h b in '
A b d a l H a m id a l
a ıM a s A r u
ıM a m n u À n w a
À h k a m , Is t a n b
u l G
A b d u r h b A b d u lh a m i d e l
E s e r i , js la m l
A ç rd a n M iiz
M u s t a fa Ö z k
I
s
ta
n bu l
,
G u r a ba
20 13 ,
,
Ą r a b ic a s A b d A lla h
p p 17
b in A b d a l H
u n ld a l
A th a r i , o l
bw
a l La hw
w a ıW b ı
d , Is t a n b u l
G u rab a
A l A th a r i a ı
, 20 0 ı
G a ln a
,
ıM u s i
w , p 1 15
A l A th a r i
l G h jn a
1 M u sl a
q
pp 1 18 24
A l A th a r i a ı
G A ln a
,
ıM tıs i a
q , p p 24 2 3
A l A th a r i o
ı
G
a
l
,
n a
ıM u s l a
q , p p 14 1 2 , 1
46 7
'
-
.
-
'
-
86
e
.
.
.
-
-
.
.
-
.
.
.
-
'
-
w
87
a
-
'
-
'
w
.
a
.
-
'
'
-
.
-
-
'
-
-
88
.
-
'
-
-
.
w
89
91
-
-
w
a
-
-
w
a
-
-
.
.
.
.
.
'
-
,
90
a
a
-
-
-
,
'
-
.
.
'
-
.
-
.
-
w
a
-
-
.
-
-
.
Scanned by CamScanner
'
99
.
T he y
am
y in g t o
th c Q u r
tr
r a th e r t h a n
26 M
100
.
Le o
n
'
a n
h 2 0 15
a r d B in d e r , Is la m
a rc
iı
c ls ı
am
re c o n c
d
a n
th c
an
su n n a
ıC u h u r e ,
y
￠
d
th c
'
in
:
W
e st; t
p 24
.
he y
(in
t e r v ie w
re
A ra b
.
ic
L ib e r a ı
ı
sm
A
C r itJq u e
o
í D ￠r ￠ıo p m
m
C h ic a g ° : U n iv e r s it y o r C h ic a g ° P r e s s 19 8 8 p 9 6 Se e
t o n t h e c r it ic a l th in k e r s M o h a m m
K e r s te n
(19 2 8 2 0 10 ) a n «l M u h a m m a d A b id a l Ja b ir i (19 3 6 20 10
M u s lim s a n d th e ir R e lig io n in a P
K e r s t e n , C r it ic a l is la m
,
,
.
.
'
c o
s
m
m
e
n
'
-
-
-
'
S in g a p °r e M id d le E a s t P a p e r s I0 , 1 (2 0 14 ) , p 1 19
H b r ld 1 7 8 0 1
10 1 C h r is t o p h e r B a y ly , T h e B ir t h o í th e M o d e r n
w e ll, 2 0 0 4 p
C o n n e c t io n s a n d C o m p a r is o n s , O x fo r d B la c k
S e e a ls o K h a le d E l R o u a )
ı
0 2 E l R o u a y h e b , F r o m Ib n H a ja r
Cu
e n t u r y S c h o lm ly
In te lle c t u a l H is t o r y in t h e S e v e n t e e n t h C
C a m b r id g e
a m b r id g e
C
e
b
h
r
a
M
e
th
,
O tto m a n E m ir e a n d
g
W
ld
o r
'
.
,
-
,
.
.
,
'
'
.
-
.
-
p
10 3
.
R id a
'
10 4
.
in s e r t s
A bd u h
Se e G
d La
an
(e d )
.
,
'
w
R is d Ta
s
e o
f
rg e M
in
L o B ic
is la
in
in
o o tn o te s
l
t
-
ta w
h id
'
a
m
k d is i , L a w
,
an
w ie s b a d e n
đm
sı
c la s s ic a l ı
jc
o
d T r a d itio
H
n a
lis m
tz
a r r a s so w i
c u ltu ıe ,
,
19 7 1
w ie s b a d e n
s
r n o t
t
in
M
in
f Ib n T a y m iyy a
p
fa u ltin g M m fo
8
5
8
]
,
)
(
r a is e
he
an
H
In s
d Jo
a r r a ss o
T
1 5 , 19 1
.
IO S
ł
o6
.
.
El R
-
o u a
s la m
yh e b , ı
ic
İn
te
or
1e c t ııo ] H is t r , p p
ı
İ H
.
-
:p
e s
p
.
Scanned by CamScanner
38
Andrew Hammond